Living plastic free: CFL Lightbulbs

Written by EnviroWoman
Live Plastic-Free in 2007
SAINT or SINNER?

I know, I know…you’re thinking…'EnviroWoman this is a no-brainer. Of course you’re buying Compact Fluorescent Lightbulbs. They use 60% less energy. They last up to 15 times longer. Every Green Guide on the planet evangelizes them as being an energy saver. And energy saviour. I think they may even be able to walk on water.'

Well, life is full of ironies. And this is one of them.

And we’re not talking an itsy-bitsy-paramecium-sized irony. We’re talking a big, honkin’ Godzilla- Meets-Tyrannosaurus-Rex-sized irony.

Yup, get ready for it….you know what’s coming….CFL light bulbs are packaged in plastic.

And not just an innocuous bit of plastic that EnviroWoman could excuse as a MINOR SIN.

But a big, bad wad of plastic. You know the stuff I’m talking about….the hard clear kind that entombs its precious cargo. The kind called ‘blister pak’…oh, so appropriately and ironically named.

The kind that has no customer-friendly ‘tear here’ pull tabs to save your precious digits.

The kind you have to do battle with. That breaks xacto-knife blades and dulls stainless steel scissors.

The kind that puts you in such an instant fit of rage TheBeast goes scrambling for cover.

The kind that if you were into conspiracy theories you would swear was an evil retail plot to prevent you from ever returning another light bulb, printer cartridge, or computer accessory ‘in its original packaging’ as so often is required.

The kind that if you were really really into conspiracy theories you would swear was an evil plot to secretly decrease the human population by making a person’s blood pressure go from 120/80 to 210/120 in sixty seconds…boiling so high they keel over dead right there on the spot.

And it gets worse. The kind of plastic that doesn’t even have a recycling code on it…so it can’t be thrown into our recycling blue boxes.

Yuppers, it’s gotta go in the garbage only to take decades and decades to degrade. Maybe even 1,000 years considering how hard and thick it is.

A veritable sheep in wolf’s clothing.

A SAINT dressed as a SINNER.

Ironic isn’t it?

EnviroWoman was so heart-wrenched by this revelation she was moved to wax poetically...

Do not go gentle into that good light,
Eco-agers should rant and rave at close of day;
Rage, rage against the plastic packaging plight.

Though EnviroWoman in her heart knows CFL is right,
Because her pledge has forced a no-new plastic way
She can not go gentle into that good light.

Rage, rage against the plastic packaging plight.

Well, its not quite as good as Dylan Thomas but ya get my point.

By now you’re probably thinking…'Holy crap, EnviroWoman is gonna have to commit a whole new category of eco-sin and buy the lowly standard light bulb.’

Ahhhh, but you know EnviroWoman is as persistent as the Pope is catholic.

She searched The Bay, and Sears, and London Drugs, and Shoppers Drug Mart and was defeated. As a last resort she googled and was steered towards Canadian Tire. There she found a cardboard packaged CFL bulb produced my NOMA.

Gotta love the Noma...they got it right. Gotta love the Canadian Tire....they got it right too.

EnviroWoman can now rid herself of rage, rage...and return to her normal chocolate-induced GiddyZen state.

So here’s how things add up:

Category: CFL lightbulbs
SAINT: NOMA
Price: The same
Quality:
The same
SINNER: Phillips, Duramax, Globe, (well, that's not very green of you guys)

Lessons Learned:

  • Sometimes the greenies get it wrong. They try to enlighten us, but sometimes we have to enlighten them. Philips, Duramax, Globe…you’re gonna hear from EnviroWoman.
 

Comments

jsmr's picture

What is more, when you break

Written by jsmr

What is more, when you break a compact flourescent, so I've heard, it releases mercury, and you have to call the EPA to come clean it up!  
Ohmygosh!

Jsmr....Well, if that's

Written by EnviroWoman

Jsmr....Well, if that's true, that's 1,000 times more than just scary.

That's crazy.

Maybe they should hand out HAZ-MAT suits when you buy them.

EnviroWoman

Plastic free. Cruelty free. Vegetarian. Chocoholic

That's actually an urban

Written by SarahH (not verified)

That's actually an urban legend. Or rather, someone did break a lightbulb, and called the EPA, who recommended expensive full cleaning of the carpet to cover all the bases so that they didn't get sued. But the amount of mercury in a CFL isn't actually nearly enough to warrant decontaminating the whole room like that. There's less in a CFL than in a mercury thermometer. You just open the windows to let any vapor escape, clean the mercury up with a rag very thoroughly (while wearing gloves!), and put it wherever you put batteries and other things that go in hazardous waste. If it were in a small child's room you might want to be a bit more paranoid, just because they're going to be much more sensitive to mercury, but it still probably doesn't require professional cleaning. And of course, non-broken dead CFLs should also go in hazardous waste. There's also a lot of research happening on how to reduce the amount of mercury needed in CFLS. There was an article about this in Treehugger a while ago.

I've been wondering about

Written by Kevin (not verified)

I've been wondering about this one myself. The other aspect of this problem: CFL's are made with plastic. That whole bottom casing bit.

Thanks for the pointer to the cardboard-packaged ones, though! This blog is really a great help in finding plastic-free alternatives.

Charnet's picture

Hmmm.......things are worse

Written by Charnet

Hmmm.......things are worse than I thought.  On the radio yesterday, a man was talking to Charles Adler about how the Toyota Prius Hybrid is produced.  Turns out the processes that are used to manufacture the batteries are much worse environmentally than if you stuck with the regular engine.  And last wednesday we were supposed to unplug our electrical devices....I heard more than one commentator say they were going to take advantage by having a candlelit dinner.  Oh yeah, that'll help.  There is a lot to be said for abstinence.

Hey again jsmr. I did a bit

Written by EnviroWoman

Hey again jsmr.

I did a bit of snooping, because I found it a bit hard to believe the EPA would have to be called in for a quick mercury clean up. So here is what I found...

In case of a bulb breakage the EPA recommends

  1. immediately open windows to reduce mercury concentrations in your home
  2. don't touch the spilled mercury (use rubber gloves)
  3. clean up the broken glass right away (carefully) but don't use a vacuum
  4. wipe the spill area with a paper towel to remove all glass fragments and the mercury.
  5. place the paper towel and glass fragments in a sealed plastic bag and take it to your local Household Hazardous Waste (HHW) Collection Site.

A CFL break doesn’t mean an expensive or complicated clean-up of the spill is needed or that you should be worried about your or your family's health…if you follow those EPa guidelines.

Here are some links to investigate this topic further.

Phew...it's not HAZ-MAT suit time. But it's still not pretty.

EnviroWoman

Plastic free. Cruelty free. Vegetarian. Chocoholic

I used to date NOMA (or at

Written by Vanessa (not verified)

I used to date NOMA (or at least the heir to the NOMA throne... his grandfather started the company), so I'll pass on the kind words :)

It's true, though. The packaging on CFLs drives me crazy.