...by not consuming

Alexandra Samuel's picture

Written by Alexandra Samuel
To Be A Conscious Consumer

I'm the consumer queen. You know how everyone has one weakness or another where they overspend? For some people it's clothes, for others food, books, music, electronics, home furnishings, kids' stuff, pet stuff -- everyone has some area where they overaccumulate.

For me it's ALL of those categories. Which is why I find myself thinking more and more about my personal consumption and how it conflicts with my values and beliefs about social and environmental sustainability.

But I'm not sure that conscious consumption is the solution, per se. OK, it's part of the solution. Buy American Apparel rather than the Gap (if you feel better about underwriting sexual harassment than underwriting cheap labour). Buy recycled paper. Buy organic. Et cetera.

The problem with all that is that in our culture, consumption isn't only -- or even primarily -- about the end of acquiring goods or services. It's really about the addictive, numbing process of acquisition: every minute I spend searching for the perfect pair of chic, waterproof black boots (suggestions, anyone?) is a minute I'm not spending in reflection about the prospect of global warming, the situation in Iraq, my kids' prospects for happiness, my mortgage, the possibility of suitcase nukes, or any of the other ten thousand anxieties that zoom through my postmodern worrybrain.

Conscious consumption is arguably a better way of channeling that numbing behaviour -- if only because non-exploitative goods are more expensive, and thus shopping consciously probably means shopping less --  but it doesn't address the underlying problem of a society in which the process of consumption is a core social, psychological and identify-forming behaviour. 

All that said, having given up so many other helpful self-medicating behaviours in the name of responsible parenting, I'm not yet willing/able to separate from my shopaholism. So my latest experiment in displacing the consumer urge has been to switch from real-world shopping (which consumes resources to produce and ship goods) to virtual shopping (which consumes a little energy, but remarkably little.) For all the other shopaholics out there who want to hit the mall without destroying the earth, I recommend checking out Second Life.

 

Comments

It's hard not to get caught

Written by Celia (not verified)

It's hard not to get caught up in the activity of acquisition itself when our whole culture is devoted to it and encourages that behaviour.

We are so much defined by our posessions; our very identities revolve around our consumption. Sad to say it, but so much of our dreams, aspirations and personal histories are defined by our consumption. Nick Hornby and Chuck Klosterman are a perfect example of how we self-identify through our consumer tastes.

We can be so self-conscious. For example: I read Vanity Fair and Nylon, but not InStyle or Glamour. I listen to The Shins, but not The Killers. I wouldn't mind being seen shopping at Spank, but never at Aritzia. I don't like admitting to these statements.

Tangentially: In the director's commentary for the movie, Master & Commander, Peter Weir talked about the difficulty of casting extras for the film. Specifically, finding actors and models who would look convincing as part of the 18th century lower classes. The models and actors they initially screened had self-conscious images and tended to project an idea of themselves. They ended up scouting for extras in remote Eastern European towns to find people who were relatively untouched by popular culture, people who would be able to look "natural" and move without being self-aware.